Radish alpha
r
rad:z4D5UCArafTzTQpDZNQRuqswh3ury
Radicle desktop app
Radicle
Git
Draft reviews
Closed { reason: Solved } did:key:z6Mki9XN...FvWF opened 10 months ago

At the moment, creating a review confuses users: When they click to add a review it is immediately published without a description or code comments. The review is added to the list but users may not notice this.

To address this we want to implement the following flow:

  1. User clicks “Review +” on the patch screen
  2. User is shown the review screen
    • the review is not published to the network
    • There is a “Publish” button in the top right corner
    • The description field is in edit mode
  3. User selects a verdict
  4. User writes a description and clicks “save”
  5. User adds line comments
  6. User clicks “Publish”
  7. User is redirected to the patch screen and the review is visible

If the user navigates away after 2. and before 6., they can find their review in the list on the patch screen. In the list, it is marked as a draft (need to figure out how). When they click on the review they can continue where they left off.

The “Publish” button is disabled, unless the user adds a description and or selects an non-neutral verdict. If the button is disabled, this is explained through a tooltip.